Thanks to everybody who has answered this question. This is my favorite question to ask in social settings because:
1. It's personal but not excessively revealing
2. The answers are always interesting
3. It usually brings up a pleasant memory for the person who is answering
4. The answer usually comes with a little story, like RadioGuy's story about throwing a fit in the record department at Sears, or Closer's story about choosing a cassette over a CD.
5. Sometimes people sing or hum or recite the "tiny little moment" that made them buy the record, which is always fun.
There's no need to be embarrassed about your first record. (Mine could so easily have been
Merry Christmas from Alvin and the Chipmunks or a Partridge Family album, but my dad bought those for me.) I ask this question a lot and at least 50% of the time the first record someone bought bears NO resemblance to their adult taste in music. The contrast is so striking that the next question is usually "Do you remember what it was about this record that made you want to buy it?" Unfortunately, they usually can't remember. (And I don't think they're lying. I interrogated my own little brother about this and he couldn't remember.) It always makes me wish we could go back and ask their younger self to find out what caught their fancy back then.
So what was it about that first record that made you buy it?
For me, it was that circus sound that starts off the song and accompanies the first line of the chorus each time. And it mentions clowns. My favorite toy as a child was my stuffed clown doll.
